Seeking blessings: An artist’s conception of the church redevelopment.
JOHN VAN KLAVEREN
OBJECTORS have lodged arguments against proposed redevelopment of a historic Geelong church, according to a council spokesperson.
The spokesperson said the six objections cited concerns about how the plans for an 80-seat cafe would affect the historical significance and building integrity of the 1865 Mt Zion Particular Baptist Church.
Last week’s Independent revealed the redevelopment bid last week, including its plans to use the Lt Ryrie St church’s baptismal font as a “water feature”.
Geelong councillor Barbara Abley said Heritage Victoria issued a permit for the works despite the concerns of City Hall officers.
“Council comment is sought by Heritage Victoria prior to a decision being made on any heritage permit application they consider,” Cr Abley said.
“Officers provided heritage advice and raised a number of concerns with the development, in particular, the projecting canopy that is to return around the front of the building and the removal of the original windows and replacement with large aluminium framed doors. Officers recommended that both of these aspects be reconsidered.
“Unfortunately, Heritage Victoria issued a permit endorsing the proposal, therefore seeming not to have agreed to any of the changes suggested.”
Cr Abley said the planning application for the site included an on-premises liquor licence.
Council officers were considering the licence application, she said.
The National Trust’s Jennifer Bantow confirmed her organisation had lodged objections.
Mrs Bantow said Heritage Victoria should have advertised the proposal instead of granting a permit without asking for a “more-sympathetic” approach.
A Heritage Victoria spokesperson said one of its officer “clarified” council’s concerns before determining that the plans did not impact the church’s heritage values.
The church’s return canopy design was renegotiated and altered in the final plans, the spokesperson said.
